Principle before rule

The American compliance culture makes the opposite bet: the rule first, whatever the spirit. In that game, a dishonest person who ticks every box can do as they please, while an honest one who breaks a rule by mistake is found at fault. Ethics is not a signed form: it starts with a simple question that anyone can ask.

Where are you coming from?

We expect a journalist to say where they are coming from. Ask the same of the people who advise you: who are you, who do you answer to, what do you stand to gain depending on whether the deal goes ahead or not, with one buyer rather than another? A declared conflict of interest can be managed. An undisclosed one distorts everything.

Your interests, and only yours

When you hire an adviser, they must defend your interests, and yours alone. Not their own, even though you will never fully avoid that. Not those of their peers. And above all not those of the financiers, investors, banks or partners circling around the deal.

Are your accountant and your lawyer enough?

They are loyal to you, and they know you better than anyone. But the day you sell, they lose a client. So they are not the most objective people to tell you whether to sell, when and to whom. They are important cogs and voices worth hearing. That is not enough.

Look elsewhere

Elsewhere means an adviser whose job is to approach buyers and investors on your behalf, in your interest. That adviser therefore cannot depend on any of them. An institution such as Bpifrance, the French public investment bank, which acts at once as equity investor, lender and guarantor, is by design not best placed to advise the entrepreneur sitting across the table.

That is the whole problem: powerful, well-funded institutions attract business owners and make the most of their position. They reinforce the idea that an adviser is unnecessary, all the better to pull the blanket to their side.

Clear-sightedness, the missing ingredient

You still have to look for it. When an entrepreneur and an investor get on well, trust sets in and the entrepreneur follows. No competing offers, no advisers around the table, whatever the price. This is a real weakness of the French economy, directly linked to France's shortcomings in economic warfare and economic intelligence.

Portrait of Alain Juillet, smiling, in a navy jacket and striped shirt, seated in a lounge.
Alain Juillet

Alain Juillet, former director of intelligence at the DGSE (France's foreign intelligence service) and then senior official in charge of economic intelligence from 2003 to 2009, has been saying it for years: the main difficulty lies in French naivety towards partners who are allies rather than friends, and who defend their own interests first. What holds for a country holds for a business owner at the negotiating table.

Watch: « La France : cible de la guerre économique » (France, a target of economic warfare), with Alain Juillet, on Open Box TV (YouTube, in French)

Don't be naive

Make the effort to consult an adviser, or several. Nothing obliges you to hire one, nothing obliges you to pay a lot. But each of them will help you frame and define your interests more clearly. After that, the decision is yours.

Considering a sale or opening your capital? Get an independent opinion before you commit.

Ask for an opinion